And, boy, did it work.
Since then, the recut trailer is a YouTube staple, showing up in all forms, possibly having reached a cultural apex when re-cut Brokeback Mountain trailers became America's favorite excuse for a hearty gay joke.
Nevertheless, the tradition continues, and we've culled together some of our favorites. Got your own suggestions? Leave 'em in the comments!
Update: Boy, did you! Here's a follow-up with readers' awesome picks!
- Mrs. Doubtfire
- When Harry Met Sally
- Mary Poppins
- You've Got Mail
- Shawshank Redemption
- Amelie
- There's Something About Mary
- Sleepless In Seattle
- The Ring
- Toy Story






















comments
I've got to say, I'm a little disappointed that you left out The Shining Recut. Good list otherwise though.
by:// marthahershour - Jun 15th 2009
@marthahershour:
Should have clarified - The Shining trailer is linked at the top!
by:// Eliot - Jun 15th 2009
@Eliot:
Yes, I saw that. But I still think it should be included in the 10 best.
by:// marthahershour - Jun 15th 2009
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v_mW8mBzmHo
This recut trailer makes me want to love the wickerman
by:// RoyceAquatic - Jun 15th 2009
o Bango dude, right on the money! I like it!
RT
www.absolute-anonymity.us.tc
by:// Jason WOods - Jun 15th 2009
Not a movie trailer but greatness. Diff'rent Strokes opening credits re-scored:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kr-e3qGQ884
by:// Michael W - Jun 15th 2009
There's a Titanic 2 cut floating around somewhere that's pretty good. I hadn't seen TOY STORY recut, that was great...
www.LaserPrintingInc.com
by:// kmlaser84 - Jun 17th 2009
mrs doubfire, i like it very much
http://acne-info-source.blogspot.com/
by:// hj - Jun 15th 2009
ahem, how can you forget:
1. American Psycho recut as a romantic comedy
2. School of Rock recut as a horror
not really "best 10" without those list imo
by:// bananas - Jun 15th 2009
Scary Mary Poppins is the best. Toy Story is great.
Mrs. Doubtfire is a side-splitter.
What about Brokeback to the Future?
by:// Bob - Jun 15th 2009
This is by far the best one I've seen!
Saving Private Ryan recut as a feel good comedy. Should have made it!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f0_Vjut7S1U
by:// Todd - Jun 15th 2009
This is my favorite by far!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f0_Vjut7S1U
It's Saving Private Ryan recut as a feel good comedy. So good!
by:// Todd - Jun 16th 2009
How can you leave out Toy Story Requem?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D1qihwMN0JM
by:// JV - Jun 16th 2009
mrs doubfire, i like it very much
wbr, http://filesmixx.com
by:// Dann - Jun 16th 2009
How about this one for Big?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-G6fU-aYq-E
by:// Justin - Jun 16th 2009
uhhh, what about "Broke Back to the Future?"
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8uwuLxrv8jY
by:// Foam - Jun 16th 2009
My personal favorite is Glen and Garry and Glen and Ross: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QipAqdomO3I
by:// Seth Christenfeld - Jun 16th 2009
Pretty good list but I definitely think that The Shawshank Redemption comedy is a TON more funny than the gay romantic one. You can watch at: http://www.allsubs.org/movie-trailer/The+Shawshank+Redemption++Trailer+(Comedy)/tyTz4oDEHRI
by:// Emma - Jun 16th 2009
ok, the sleepless in seattle one sucked bug time, they did not explain any kind of story.
The best one was probably the ring, because it took the most actual talent.
The toy story one is pretty good, i like the visuals, but the audio editing in that one was the worst aspect of all of them.
by:// Neil - Jun 16th 2009
There's a couple of good ones for The Incredibles.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iqBNNpvz2BY&feature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=slQOVh5v7Ns
by:// Luke - Jun 17th 2009